The following story worthy of Dickens, or perhaps Wilkie Collins, was reported in the Dublin Morning Register, 4 September 1835, and the Leeds Times, 19 September 1835:

[Margaret Feltis], who is only 17 years of age, was left an orphan, and taken [in} by her uncle… a man of excellent character, of the name of John Love, who… holds the situation of tipstaff in the Four Courts. [He] gave her permission… to go to the neighbourhood of Ferns, in the County of Wexford… to visit her aunt… her uncle received no tidings of her [until] a woman called at his residence, and stated to him that… his niece… had died in the month preceding.

Last July Mr Love received a letter from the head turnkey of Kilmainham gaol, stating that Margaret Feltis was under sentence of transportation, having been convicted in Wexford of vagrancy. [He] immediately repaired to Kilmainham.. it was not until a convict ship was on the point of sailing… that his efforts were finally successful.”

The unfortunate Margaret had apparently

“witnessed a robbery committed by some men who were related to a female living under the protection of an individual of some influence… this female was the contriver of a plot which [by arranging Margaret’s wrongful arrest and informing her uncle of her supposed death] put the only witness against her relatives out of the way, and, thus screened them from their well-merited punishment.”

The unnamed ‘gentleman of influence’ must have been very influential indeed, because no further investigation seems to have taken place.

Was transportation really used as a means of nobbling witnesses? Or was the whole extraordinary tale merely an Irish Franchise Affair – the imaginative creation of a teenager who had landed in trouble with the law after faking her death to evade avuncular supervision?

A scary story no matter which way you look at it!

Image Credit

Image Context

Ruth Cannon avatar

Published by

Categories:

4 responses to “The Terrifying Tale of the Tipstaff’s Niece, 1835”

  1. Heather Rendall avatar
    Heather Rendall

    Do you have any information about Joseph Cobbe who was a tipstaff at Four Courts 1840s-1850s?

    1. Ruth Cannon BL avatar

      Heather, sorry for the delay in replying. There was a Mr Cobbe who was Overseer of the Board of Works at the Four Courts in the 1830s. Effectively he was the general manager of the buildings there. There was also a John Cobb, Courtkeeper of the Nisi Prius Court from 1840s-1860s, who was charged in 1867 with the theft of a number of chairs from the court. I am not sure whether he was convicted or not.

  2. rebecca moore avatar
    rebecca moore

    Hi there, was there any follow up with this Margaret Feltis? What happened to her or anything of that nature?

    My gr-gr-gr Grandmother Margaret Feltis was married in Canada in 1839 – born approx. 1814 Ireland – father from Wexford Ireland and noted as deceased.
    I came across this article and wondered if this could be my line- after something like this she might have left for Canada (she had brothers over here already)

    Is there any details of her Uncle John Love; who his wife was?

    1. Ruth Cannon avatar

      Rebecca, if I find any further details I will let you know. Regards, Ruth

Leave a Reply

Contact Us

Discover more from Sharing the History of the Four Courts, Dublin

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading