Judges
The head of the 19th century Irish legal system was the Lord Chancellor of Ireland (the premier judge in the Court of Chancery), with the Lord Chief Justice of Ireland (the premier judge in the Court of King’s Bench) coming next in precedence. There followed the Chief Justice of the Common Pleas in Ireland and the Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer. All were assisted by puisne judges also assigned to the relevant court.
There was also a Rolls Court run by the Lord Chancellor’s Deputy, the Master of the Rolls in Ireland. Later, there was an Admiralty Court, a Bankruptcy Court, an Encumbered/Landed Estates Court and a Probate Court. All of these had designated judges presiding over them.
The above system was changed by the Supreme Court of Judicature (Ireland) Act 1877, which converted the original four courts of Chancery, King’s Bench, Exchequer and Common Pleas into divisions of a single High Court of Justice. By 1897 the four divisions of the High Court of Justice had been reduced to two: Chancery and King’s Bench. The 1877 Act also created a Court of Appeal in Ireland
The creation of the Irish Free State in 1922 was followed by the Courts of Justice (Ireland) Act 1924. This Act replaced the Court of Appeal in Ireland with a Supreme Court and a Court of Criminal Appeal. The High Court of Justice was replaced by a new High Court of the same name, but without divisions, and a Central Criminal Court took the place of the previous Assize jurisdiction of the High Court, which had involved High Court judges travelling outside Dublin to preside over trials for serious criminal offences.
-
Baron Dowse and the Saga of the Stand-Up Desk, 1871
A stand-up row about a stand-up desk between the usually genial Irish Solicitor-General Richard Dowse, later Baron Dowse of the Irish Court of Exchequer (above right), and Mr Ayrton of the Westminster Board of Works, gives us an interesting insight… Continue reading
-
Legal Duels in the Phoenix Park, 1760-1800
From the Newcastle Courant, 12 May 1882, an article, inspired by the Phoenix Park murders, reminiscing about the blood previously spilled in that location by Irish legal duellists, including future Lord Chief Justices of the Common Pleas and King’s Bench… Continue reading
-
The Family of Mr Justice Keogh in the Shade of the Sugar Loaf, 1857
The family of William Nicholas Keogh, Judge of the Common Pleas in Ireland (1856-78), beautifully depicted by John Joseph Slattery in 1857 against the backdrop of the Sugar Loaf, Wicklow, in 1857. Keogh, a former M.P. as well as Q.C.,… Continue reading
-
Anonymous Letters to Judges: The Less Nice Sort, 1880
Although no one could have called 19th century Irish judges overworked, and their depth of legal knowledge varied radically, they all had one thing in common, and that was a high degree of physical courage. With the murder of Lord… Continue reading
-
Anonymous Letters to Judges – The Nicer Sort, 1895
Judge Boyd, Bankruptcy Judge, occasionally received anonymous correspondence asking for special consideration for persons due to appear before him. While such correspondence tended to be politer than most anonymous letters received by 19th century Irish judges, he exceedingly disliked these… Continue reading